In retirement villages,
many units are joined together in duplex pairs,
standalone units are mostly close to each other,
and some units are joined together in terraces.
In lifestyle villages,
the units are physically separate from each other
but are usually densely packed together.
In both types of residential village,
mosquito coil smoke simply shifts any mosquitoes
from one residence to another.
Smoke repels mosquitoes,
but only from the smoky area immediately downwind
of the mosquito coil.
If there are any mosquitoes present,
then they just move
in all directions
out of the smoke.
Most if not all of the mosquitoes will
remain in the village.
Burning a mosquito coil might
make it less likely that one resident will be
bitten by mosquitoes,
but then some other resident will become more likely to be bitten.
Only a relatively small proportion of residents
burn mosquito coils.
Unless coils are burned simultaneously
by a high proportion of the residents in a village,
the smoke cannot significantly reduce
the number of mosquitoes in the village.
The practice of burning mosquito coils
in a residential village
therefore provides little or no overall
anti-mosquito benefit for the village.
Residents who claim to rely on mosquito coils
consider themselves to be unprotected
from mosquito bites
when coils are not being burned.
To be considered effective,
the coils have to be burned continuously all day long.
Consequently, the smoke nuisance
from mosquito coils is continuously present all day long.
Summarising the effects of burning mosquito coils
in a residential village,
the coils do not substantially reduce
the overall number of mosquitoes
so they probably do not reduce the overall number of bites,
some residents burn coils all day long
which creates smoke all day long,
other residents cannot escape from the smoke,
which can be an unpleasant nuisance
and causes health hazards
for those who are forced to breathe it,
and coils are burned
even when there are no mosquitoes.
The evidence is overwhelming that
mosquito coils are an inappropriate
method of preventing mosquito bites
in residential villages.
Perhaps "appalling" might well
be a more accurate description
than "inappropriate".
Thanks to modern anti-mosquito measures,
in many places
mosquito coils are unnecessary
for most of the time
because for most of the time
there are few if any mosquitoes.
In any case, at all times
mosquito coils are fundamentally unnecessary
because there are better ways to prevent mosquito bites.
A good example of a preventative measure
that is more effective than mosquito coils,
and that causes no harm to other people,
is wearing clothes that prevent mosquito bites.
Another good example is mosquito repellent.
Ultrasonic mosquito repellers
are another good example.
Many people find them very effective.
These inexpensive battery-powered devices
repel mosquitoes by
emitting high frequency sounds
that human ears cannot hear.
An effective method for reducing mosquito numbers
is by adding special chemicals to standing water.
These prevent mosquitoes
from breeding and do not harm other wildlife.
A fly swatter is the
most environmentally-friendly method
of zapping mosquitoes.
Legislation: The Retirement Villages Act (Queensland 1999)
states that residents must not unreasonably interfere,
or unreasonably cause or permit interference,
with the peace, comfort or privacy of other residents.
Repeatedly creating smoke that causes a nuisance
and health hazards
to neighbours
is clearly a breach of this law.
Negligently, where smoke is concerned,
this law rarely ever appears to be enforced.
Similarly to noise pollution,
air pollution is a contentious issue.
Some people don't seem to mind smoke pollution,
whereas others cannot tolerate excessive smoke.
Most residential villages in Queensland have rules
that restrict how much noise a resident can make.
But oddly, for smoke pollution there are usually no restrictions,
other than some sort of vague and ineffectual rule
that tobacco smokers should be mindful of other residents.
What about mosquito coils, incinerators and fish smokers?
In Queensland some villages also
have firepits for communal use,
sometimes situated on the upwind side of the village.
Mosquito coils are widely used.
Smoke from mosquito coils creates a nuisance
and health hazards.
Yet mosquito coils are not specifically mentioned in any legislation.
There is a need for reform of
the current laws relating to all types
of smoke pollution in Queensland.
Common Law: In many countries,
it is now accepted that passive tobacco smoking is a health hazard.
In contrast, in Queensland the established common law appears to be
that an "ordinary person" would never find that cigarette smoke
constitutes an "unreasonable interference",
nomatter what circumstances exist
such as the most prevalent direction of the wind
and how much of the time that there is smoke
and whether there is any necessity for the smoke.
Despite a progressive marginalisation of tobacco smoking
in most parts of the world,
in Queensland the laws relating to smoke nuisance
have not kept pace with what is
generally accepted to be in the public interest.
Nevertheless, the tide in Queensland may have started to turn.
In 2021,
an Adjudicator for the
Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management
barred a unit holder at Artique Resort, Surfers Paradise,
from smoking tobacco products on their balcony
after a complaint from another unit holder.
In this landmark case the Adjudicator introduced to Queensland
a concept that had previously been adopted in New South Wales,
the concept being that tobacco smoke is always a hazard
because there is no safe level of exposure to it.
In Queensland before this ruling,
any court-imposed prohibition
on smoking at a residence would have been unthinkable.
Although the Artique case involved a strata title scheme,
which is governed by a different law from residential villages,
it seems likely that prohibitions on smoke pollution
will eventually become normal
in all types of close-proximity residential communities
including retirement villages and lifestyle villages.